The question of what works better out of a straight and curved pruning saw is one that many gardeners would be curious to know the answer to. After looking into it, I decided to write a post that includes all relevant information on this topic.
Straight and curved pruning saws are both highly useful in particular situations. A straight saw is better suited for pruning somewhere between the height of your shoulders and waist. A curved saw is more useful when either pruning above head height or below the waist.
The reason for the saws being better suited for use at different heights is due to the logistics of the human body. More of the comparisons and benefits of both will be explained in detail in the next sections.
Things worth considering when choosing a straight or curved pruning saw
As I touched upon in the introductory section, the main functional difference between the two saw types is the heights they allow you to prune comfortably.
Using the wrong type of saw will make the process of pruning less safe, produce unsatisfactory results and potentially make you vulnerable to repetitive strain injuries.
This makes it very important that you take some time to analyze the branches or stalks that you want to prune.
Where do they measure up to on your body? Are they comfortably within reach, or do they require you to reach up vertically? Answering these questions and establishing what you’re working with before purchasing your pruning saw is a must, as it will save you a lot of hassle in the long run.
Considerations for choosing between a straight or curved pruning saw
The height you intend to be pruning at is the most important factor to consider, but it is not the only one.
Curved and straight saws also have different sawing capabilities that should also be noted. Here is a breakdown of the numerous factors considered when asking what works better, straight vs. curved pruning saws.
|The height you intend to prune at to your body.||The thickness of the branches or stalks.|
|Accessibility of the branches or stalks.||Species/type of plant.|
Your experience using a saw is also an important factor in choosing which of the saws to purchase.
For multi-purpose usage, choose the straight saw
You might be thinking, “I want to use my pruning saw at different heights.” If it is the case that you intend to use the saw on numerous plants and trees which are diverse in stature, it is better to get a straight-bladed saw.
The reason for choosing a straight saw is that it provides you with more options when pruning and is generally easier on the body.
Another bonus is that it is multi-purposed and can be used for DIY around the house, whether you are lopping off wood or cutting out a frame on a wall.
To summarize this section, both curved and straight pruning saws are equally effective in their own field, but straight saws boast more versatility, so if you were only to get one, that would be my recommendation.
The strengths and weaknesses of a curved pruning saw
If you are to be doing a lot of sawing above your head or below waist level, this is where a curved pruning saw really excels.
Due to the curved blade design, the curved saw can really dig into the wood in this position.
It also feels much easier on your body to use a curved blade in these awkward positions than it would a straight pruning saw.
Considerations for the curved pruning saw
The weaknesses of a curved pruning saw are mainly to do with their limited versatility. Other than high or low pruning, they make the sawing process more difficult at other heights.
This is because we naturally saw back in forth in a straight line, providing we are using it within a comfortable reaching range.
A curved blade means the motion must be slightly arched, making it less comfortable and less effective.
Overall a curved pruning saw should only be used for those awkward high or low positions that are difficult to get at with a regular straight pruning saw, but other than for that purpose, their effectiveness is limited.
The strengths and weaknesses of a straight pruning saw
Now let’s look in detail at the pros and cons of a straight pruning saw.
|Pros of using a straight pruning saw||Cons of using a straight pruning saw|
|A straight saw is adept at making cuts somewhere within the range of your waist level and shoulder level.||A straight pruning saw is unsuitable for cutting in awkward positions, especially high up or low down.|
|It is versatile. Because of its simple design, the straight blade can be used for many purposes, including woodwork and other household building projects.||The straight angle makes it difficult to apply pressure and can cause damage to your wrist if you use it in these positions that are tricky to access.|
Using the straight pruning saw will make the sawing process quicker and more efficient in most cases.
It essentially promotes a natural cutting motion that is less strenuous on the body due to you being apple to put your weight into the cutting process, speeding it up.
How to make pruning easier with either a straight or curved saw
Pruning can be an enjoyable task to undertake, but it can also be pretty hard work. Thankfully, you can follow certain methods to make the process as easy as possible and minimize the risks involved.
- It’s highly important to prune your branches equally, considering the side branches too. If you provide an all over prune but neglect these side branches, it will result of unsightly regrowth which makes the tree look like it has a weird shape.
- Be sure to wear protective gloves and if you are looking up while pruning, eye protection will prevent loose trimmings from causing an injury.
- If you are removing larger limbs, it’s important to make a slight undercut that is around 30 cm from the trunk. This will prevent a tear from occurring and the stub will be cleanly cut off after pruning.
Smaller trees can be pruned and tidied up in the spring and summer. Maintaining them in this way will prevent you from having a mammoth task on your hands every couple of years.
It is easier to keep the smaller trees tidy with slight trims than to spend days trying to prune them in their entirety.
Working with the trees and pruning habits
When you decide which saw works better for your needs, go and analyze the trees you will be pruning. It’s always a good idea to work with the tree rather than against it.
By this, if a tree naturally forms a certain shape, try to enhance or tidy that shape rather than completely ignoring the tree’s intentions.
Working with the way a tree is naturally growing will result in a much tidier result, and less work will need to be done to achieve it.
Be very careful not to over prune your trees
Take your time pruning your trees, especially since the after-effects of over-pruning them can take years to resolve. The chances are it will continue to grow that way in years to come, which may be dangerous for the tree and yourself as the tree owner.
Over pruning your trees can really damage them and set their growth back. Allowing all sorts of illness and disease to take hold as you have weakened the tree. To ensure you do not over-prune your tree I recently wrote this article on over-pruning trees and how you can fix the damage caused. You really should check this one out
Conclusion on straight vs curved pruning saws
It is much easier to use a straight pruning saw between waist and shoulder height because you can keep all saw’s teeth contacting the branches. If you were to use a curved saw in this position, it would be challenging. The arch of the blade would tend to pull away from the branch, making it difficult to get a clean cut.
Hopefully, all this information can aid you in making your decision on which pruning saw to buy. At the end of the day, it all boils down, giving you better ease in cutting and ensuring the user’s safety.
If you liked this article, be sure to subscribe in the form below to be notified about future content and releases!